Saturday, January 28, 2012

Oakland Raiders



To Serve and Protect
Police Motto

This is a prime example of how subtly pernicious corporate propaganda is.  Today, Oakland police raided an Occupy rally.  The headline of a CNN article says "19 Occupy activists arrested in Oakland after clashing with police."  The first sentence of the article is: "Occupy activists tossed pipes, bottles, burning flares and other objects Saturday at Oakland police, who responded by using tear gas and smoke grenades and arresting 19 demonstrators, police said."

Notice how "police said" is buried at the end of the paragraph.  A more factual rendering would begin with: "Police claimed without providing evidence that Occupy activists..." Reporters, regardless of their political views, want access to the authorities for information and interviews so they won't overtly say or do anything to put the police in a bad light.  They know that if they don't frame the story in a favorable way, they will lose access.  This means that, barring any hard evidence to the contrary, they will report whatever the police say at face value.  That then becomes the narrative regardless of what actually happened.  It is at least as likely that the police claimed there was a "clash" to cover their own behinds. 

Police stations around the country are becoming increasingly militarized.  Clearly, the Oakland police department is leading the charge.  This is the same district where BART police officer Johannes Mehserle fatally shot Oscar Grant in the back of the head while he was unarmed and pinned to the ground.  Mehserle served two years for "involuntary manslaughter."  Oakland was also the site of the violent crackdown against Occupiers that left Iraq veteran Scott Olsen with a fractured skull.  Police in Oakland have also arrested a journalist, lacerated a man's spleen by beating him with batons while he was handcuffed, fired a rubber bullet at a man who was filming police, and allowed a hit-and-run driver who ran over protesters to leave the scene without charges.


It may or may not be true that activists threw things at the police.  But even if a handful of people lobbed water bottles at a few hundred cops who were wearing bullet-proof vests, helmets and gas masks while carrying shields and truncheons, that doesn't justify a violent crackdown against all 2,000 or so of the protesters who included children.  The degree of force that the police deployed dwarfs anything that protesters might summon in a pinch. 

The bottom line is, there was no "clash" regardless of what may or may not have happened, or why.  It was completely one-sided.  Some people may have vehemently objected to their impending arrest for speaking.  But the police cracked down violently, using chemical weapons and explosive devices then beating and arresting people among hundreds who had peaceably assembled.  American citizens were attacked by paramilitary police and arrested for speaking, because they were criticizing the plutocratic elite.  The First Amendment and the right to speech that it enshrines so concisely is becoming almost entirely meaningless in America. 

As this blog post goes to print, the number of arrests is continuing to climb and may be in the dozens or hundreds.

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Liberty and Justice for All


I pledged allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands every day in school when I was a child as I know you did.  I firmly believed in that pledge, because I was taught that in the American Dream everyone had an equal opportunity to be anyone and do anything in the freest fairest country in the world.  I believed our politicians served the public and our government guaranteed our rights. 

Today I have a different view of my country.  I still believe in America, but I believe in it the way I would believe in a relative who had a drinking problem.  I love this country with all my heart, I want it to overcome its problems more than anything, but I know the battle is uphill and time is running out. 

In 2008, Wall Street, the White House and the Federal Reserve conspired to reorganize the economy around financial monopoly.  After 30 years of eroding the New Deal protections against dangerous speculation, failed banks nearly brought the economy to its knees.  We The People bailed out Wall Street to prevent a second Great Depression.  We were forced to write a blank check worth a generation of growth with no strings attached.  There was no major reform to re-erect the wall between investment and commercial banking.  There have been no investigations, no charges, no trials to root out the corruption.  The plutocracy picked the poor’s pockets and mugged the middle class.  They smashed America’s piggy banks full of mortgage payments, college funds and retirement savings.  They took our money to tally historic profits and CEO bonuses while laying off their employees.  

We don’t argue against the merits of using trade to engender productivity, commerce and invention.  We know Capitalism is the fire that fuels growth.  But fire needs to be contained to be useful.  We need to regulate finance to harness its creative power for the good of society, while preventing it from unleashing its destructive potential.  A fire can keep your house warm and put hot meals on your table if you contain it in your fire place.  That same fire will burn your house down if you let it spread to the walls.  Those who argue that we should not regulate Wall Street are arguing that we should light our walls on fire to keep our house warm. 

Under our unregulated radical capitalism, the plutocracy orchestrated inverse Marxism for themselves: a welfare state in which the top 2% own more than the bottom 90%; a control economy in which the richest hog all the profits while the laborers shoulder all the penalties. 

From the Atlantic coast to the shores of Hawaii, an Iron Ceiling has descended across the country.  Beneath that Ceiling lies the disappearing middle class and its endeavors to produce American culture.  Above the Iron Ceiling a few hundred billionaires and a few dozen conglomerations dictate the direction of our society from the shadows.  Above the Iron Ceiling, Wall Street makes our elected officials dance on strings of gold. 

This degree of divide between the rich and the rest has not been seen since the Great Depression.  One in five children face poverty, hunger and homelessness.  Half of young adults are unemployed or underemployed while enslaved to Sallie Mae debts of tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars for an education that hasn’t opened any doors.  In numbers not seen since the 1940s, the young are putting off leaving home, getting married and starting families.  Middle aged folks are struggling to support their families.  They are working longer and longer hours to pay the mortgage, feed the family and put the kids through school.  Older Americans are delaying retirement.  They are stuck in the race after crossing the finish line, taking menial jobs to stave off poverty in their golden years.  Some have faced horrible decisions about whether to bankrupt their families to cover medical costs or accept an early grave. 

Amid all this, the ratio of average rent to average income has tripled since the 1970s.  The middle class has not had a raise in a quarter century.  Homelessness has increased by a third since 2007.  Meanwhile, millions of foreclosed homes gather dust while people shiver on the sidewalk. 

Yet, our economy is still growing.  Our Gross Domestic Product is as strong as ever.  Since the 1980s, the top 1% have lit cigars to celebrate their income doubling, tripling, quadrupling, while the middle class has flat-lined.  Since the Great Recession, the middle class is getting poorer while the rich, who caused the crash, are becoming stupendously wealthy. 

This situation was entirely avoidable.  The New Deal tamed the boom and bust cycle and enforced economic justice.  In the last thirty years, the very rich have bought both parties and all three branches of government and used them to dismantle the New Deal.  Their massive media companies saturate our discourse with pro-corporate propaganda.  Many pundits are merely corporate marionettes who sling names and innuendo at anyone who questions the billionaires’ agenda.    

There are over 25 lobbyists for every one member of Congress.  By a rate of 10 to 1, those lobbyists represent large corporations over any other interest.  They create a pervasive culture of bribery, favors and gifts.  Corruption is the norm in this town.  Lobbyists write their own legislation for their corporate clients and bribe our representatives to vote for it.  Wall Street used K Street to sideline Main Street and take our democracy away from us. 

Their control over our Congress is rapidly snowballing.  The Citizens United ruling allows Super PACs to flood our campaigns with millions and millions of secret dollars.  With campaigns so expensive, an honest politician who refused to be corrupted would drown under a tsunami of negative advertising from shadowy sources. 

The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law prohibiting free speech.  Free speech.  Not expensive speech.  Free speech is the dam that holds back the flood of tyranny.  As long as We The People have an absolute right to express ourselves, we will always be a free people.  But the corporate puppet masters seek to make speech too expensive for us, so that only they will have the right to speak.  Corporate Big Brother tells us words are not speech but dollars are.  If money is free speech, then logically, buying crack, paying a prostitute and hiring a hitman are all forms of protected speech.  As a society, we have decided that paying for those things should be illegal.  So obviously, it must be illegal to buy a politician or an election.   

Since September, we have been sounding the alarm.  We occupied Wall Street.  And the corporations flexed their muscles.  They have privatized municipal police departments around the country with huge corporate gifts and they sent the cops after us.  We have seen the images of a veteran who served his country in Iraq terribly wounded while serving his country by protesting corruption.  We have seen students pepper sprayed for the audacity of sitting together in a park.  Nearly 6,000 people have been arrested for speaking in public.  Nearly 300 have needed medical treatment after being beaten or gassed for the sin of peaceably assembling.  Still, zero bankers have been arrested, charged or jailed for the illegal trading that blew up our economy. 

By taking our message to the streets, the Occupiers have captured America’s imagination and seized the moment.  They have flushed out the corporate puppets that seek to ridicule, undermine and intimidate anti-corruption protesters into silence.  We are recreating our public sphere while the corporations seek to shut it down.  A vibrant public sphere is essential to democracy.  The Founders saw that the marketplace of ideas was the key to their early organization and ultimate success against the British crown.  In the years before the Declaration of Independence, the 13 colonies were abuzz with underground newspapers debating political ideas, publishing houses cranking out pamphlets, protests on public squares which evolved into boycotts, coffeehouses serving up hours of caffeinated discussion.  These sparks of public debate lit the fire of Revolution on which our nation was founded.  Today, we are keeping our Founders’ vision alive by carrying on the ancient discussion of what makes a free and fair society. 

The beauty of open discourse assessed under the bright light of reason is that good ideas gain steam and bad ideas fall to the wayside.  In a healthy democracy, bad ideas are not dangerous because they inevitably self-destruct.  If Occupy had bad ideas, everyone could safely ignore us.  Regressive mayors, funded by corporations, wielding privatized and militarized police departments, have ordered a crackdown on the Occupation BECAUSE our ideas have merit.  Our ideas that America’s economy should be democratic and work for our whole society are dangerous ideas BECAUSE they are good ideas. 

Our ideas are a profound threat to the power structure that enriches the wealthy elite.  The police raids against the Occupation announce that the billionaires running our country will use all their formidable influence to crush any notion of economic justice or government accountability.  But they are terrified.  They know that their position is morally untenable.  They know that if the people awaken to the reality of the power dynamics in our institutions, they will fall.  We can no longer tiptoe around the issue of class war.  The 1% have openly declared total war on the middle class who are becoming poor and the poor who are becoming desperate. 

We have come here today to draw a line in the sand.  Big money has pushed our democracy to the edge of a cliff.  Below lies an abyss of ceaseless corruption which can only lead to poverty, decline and tyranny.  We will not let you push us any further.  You picked this fight, but we will make you wage it on our terms and on our turf.  We will use the power of nonviolence, as demonstrated by Mohandas Gandhi and Martin Luther King, to monopolize the moral high ground the same way you have monopolized our economy.  We will adapt and evolve.  Kick us out of parks and we will Occupy foreclosed homes.  We will be Bugs Bunny to Wall Street’s Elmer Fudd, Roadrunner to the corporate Wile E. Coyote.  

We have come here today to stage an intervention in Congress’ addiction to Wall Street’s cash.  To tell Congress: say no to corruption.  Represent the needs and wants of your constituents.  We need a new New Deal for a new era of economic suffering and we want jobs.  We are here to tell Congress: restore the Glass-Steagall Act that prevented banks from gambling with people’s homes; Amend the Constitution to outlaw Citizens United and any law that gives corporations a free pass to expensive speech.  Cap the outrageous costs of our for-profit healthcare and higher education industries.  Congress: restore the level playing field for the middle class.  Congress: tear down the Iron Ceiling that the 1% paved over the 99%.  Congress: relight the torch of the American Dream. 

Today, I pledge allegiance to the people of the United States of America and to the Republic which we built with our labor.  I pledge to resist unjust laws.  To boycott corrupting banks and corporations.  To vote corrupt politicians out of office.  I pledge to educate myself, my friends and my family about the role of creeping greed in America.  To inform the public and expose corporate propaganda.  I pledge to support the Occupation.  I pledge that we will occupy Wall Street, occupy K Street, occupy Main Street and take control of the economy and the government back to the American people so together we can restore America to one nation, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. 




Occupy the Open Mic

So there I was standing in a sea of about 2,000 Occupiers from around the country literally in the shadow of Congress.  I was all pumped up to give the speech I had spent a weekend preparing to lambaste Congress loudly and closely enough that they might actually hear it.  I found the open-mic coordinator and told her I was here for my time slot.  Our conversation went like this:

Me: I’m here for the 6:30 time slot.
Her: What’s your name?
Me: Marc Belisle.
Her: You’re not on the list.
Me: I signed up a week ago.  I double checked the wiki today and I was still on it.  
Her: Okay, no problem.  We have a free time slot coming up anyway. 
Me: Okay, good. 
Her: So do you have an instrument or something?
Me: No, I’m giving a speech.
Her: Oh, that’s why you’re not on the list.  We had to move speeches off the mic. 
Me: What?
Her: Yeah, when we opened up the mic, we had politicians signing up to speak.  The organizers didn’t want that and we decided it wouldn’t be fair if we had to pick who could speak and who couldn’t, so we just decided to cancel speeches in general.  We sent out an email about that to everyone.  Didn’t you get the email?
Me: No.  No, I didn’t.  I did not get that email. 
Her: Oh, sorry. 

And that is the story of how I didn’t give a speech at Occupy Congress. 

I’m convinced that closing the mic to speeches is a major tactical error and a missed opportunity.  Honestly, I’m not saying this to gripe.  Obviously I’m disappointed but I’m not mad at anyone.  I’m saying it because I really want the Occupation to succeed.  I also don’t believe that my speech is so important or anyone else’s would have been.  But I do believe that speech itself is important.  It would have been a very powerful symbol to open a platform for open political discourse virtually on the steps of Congress. 

Instead, you had people playing music and reading slam poetry.  Granted, I was only there for an hour, and your event went on all day, so I can’t comment in general.  But from what I saw, it seemed that most presenters had either taken the sound-byte chants of Occupy marches and set them to folk guitar or rehashed them into snappy little couplets.  Or both.  That’s all cool, but you’re not inviting anyone into the movement when you’re just using the mic to reiterate the lingo that you use with each other. 

I’m trying to understand what exactly it was the organizers were afraid of.  I know that Occupy has been sensitive about being co-opted by professional liberals.  But allowing someone to speak is not the same as endorsing their speech.  Besides, let’s say someone like Marion Barry came to Occupy Congress and sneakily used your lingo to his own ends.  So what?  That’s not co-opting the movement.  As long as he’s not giving you money, he doesn’t have any say in how the movement is run.  Or let’s imagine the opposite.  Say Eric Cantor walked out of the Capitol, down the steps, hopped up onto your stage, grabbed the mic and called you all a bunch of filthy communists and intoned about the wonders of capitalism for fifteen minutes.  First of all, you wouldn’t even be able to hear him over all the booing.  But again, so what?  Would it not have been an opportunity to allow one of your detractors enough rope to hang himself?  Or to find some common ground with someone of a different philosophy, and thereby—to paraphrase Abraham Lincoln—destroy an enemy by turning him into a friend? 

I think it’s important to always keep in mind who the real enemies are.  The real enemies are the purveyors of very big money who use that money to corrupt our political system for their own ends.  Everyone else is a potential friend.  And in the battle of winning hearts and minds, apart from nonviolent demonstration, well-crafted open discourse is the most potent weapon we have.  I realize that there is this all-consuming ethos of ‘the movement is the message.’  But in the fight to stay in the parks, you’re losing to municipal authorities and the weather.  Camping out needed to be phase one.  If nothing else, you should have at least opened the mic for a dialogue along the lines of: what should phase two be?  You obviously can’t beat Wall Street on ability to fund and organize.  So you have to argue more convincingly than they do.  Occupy needs to be about ideas, not about clinging to a few square acres of real estate.  The decision to close off discourse is a self-inflicted wound. 

Walking around the West lawn of the Capitol, every single person I saw seemed to be a hardened veteran of Occupations.  I didn’t notice any DC residents poking around the event out of curiosity.  The first weekend that Stop the Machine set up shop here in DC, at any given time there were about 2 locals to every 1 Occupier, because they had prepared interactive demonstrations, and they even had an outreach tent.  They seemed to be getting people to think and to feel strong outrage, what with the boots and dogtags of fallen soldiers. 

I’m not saying you had to go to that extent.  What I’m saying is that there seemed to be this bright red line between them and us.  And ‘them’ seemed to be anyone who hadn’t been camping in a park for the last few months.  I wore a tie for my speech, and as I was walking around, I received several snide or suspicious comments about my dress.  I am not The Man.  I was not judging you.  I did feel a little judged myself though.  I wore the tie to create the symbolism that an average American supports you.  Maybe you don’t want average Americans to support you?  If so, I believe that’s a potentially fatal mistake.  Occupy risks irrelevancy if you allow a herd mentality to begin defining the movement. 

For what it’s worth, this is the speech I had prepared.

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

You Are Invited!

You are cordially invited to attend a speech that I will deliver on the steps of Congress.  The speech is entitled "Liberty and Justice For All" and will incorporate themes that I've written about in this blog.  It is part of Occupy Congress' open mic.  I will speak for 15 minutes at 6:30 PM on Tuesday, January 17th on the West lawn of the Capitol building. 

Come support and watch me help the Occupiers deliver our message to Congress, the message of our Founders: that government derives its power from the consent of the governed.

Links for the event:

http://www.occupyyourcongress.info/

http://wiki.occupyyourcongress.info/index.php?title=Sign_Up_Page_for_Open_Mic


Sunday, January 8, 2012

The Hunt

I know our first ancestor
echoing across the grand
canyon of an age ducked in

to the cave after an unlucky hunt
to face his moaning children’s sunken
eyes.  He wrapped their shoulders

in bear skin, showed them
to pluck a smoking stick
from the fire, sketch a bison

with the charcoal tip upon
the cool shale.  For a time
soot spears pierced wool hide

twig people ripped open the animal
grilled its flesh, filled their bellies
and danced under the stars

on the wall of rock.  He who
passed his bones down showed
us the imagination is a hawk.